| 1 | 1954 | Indianapolis | Jack Hinkle | 2 | McGRATH Jack | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 1 | 3 | |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Mel Wiggers | 10 | BETTENHAUSEN Tony | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 21 | 29 | Connecting rod |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Belond Equa-Flow/Calif. Muffler | 15 | PARSONS Johnnie | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 15 | 32 | Engine |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Sumar/Chapman Root | 19 | DAYWALT Jimmy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 2 | 27 | Accident |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Hopkins/Motor Racers | 35 | O'CONNOR Pat | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 12 | 21 | Spin |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Bardahl/Ed Walsh | 38 | RATHMANN Jim | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 28 | 28 | |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Bardahl/Ed Walsh | 38 | HOLLAND Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Jones & Maley Cars | 51 | HOMEIER Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 18 | 33 | Accident |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | McNamara/Lee Elkins | 73 | NAZARUK Mike | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 14 | 5 | |
| 1954 | Indianapolis | Merz Engineering/Milt Marion | 77 | AGABASHIAN Fred | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 24 | 6 | |
| 2 | 1955 | Indianapolis | Jack Hinkle | 3 | McGRATH Jack | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 3 | 26 | Magneto |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Lindsey Hopkins | 4 | VUKOVICH Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 5 | 25 | Fatal accident |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | John Zink | 6 | SWEIKERT Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 14 | 1 | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Jones & Maley Cars | 8 | HANKS Sam | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 6 | 19 | Transmission |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Ed Walsh | 9 | WEBB Spider | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Ed Walsh | 9 | PARSONS Johnnie | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | H.A. Chapman | 10 | RUSSO Paul | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | 2 | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | H.A. Chapman | 10 | BETTENHAUSEN Tony | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 2 | 2 | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 14 | AGABASHIAN Fred | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 4 | 32 | Spin |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Trio Brass Foundry / Anderson | 16 | PARSONS Johnnie | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 27 | 21 | Magneto |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | McNamara/Lee Elkins | 73 | DUNCAN Len | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Merz Engineering | 77 | HOMEIER Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | 5 | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Merz Engineering | 77 | FAULKNER Walt | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 7 | 5 | |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Peter Schmidt | 88 | AYULO Manuel | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | Fatal accident |
| 1955 | Indianapolis | Bardahl/Ed Walsh | 99 | CROSS Art | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 24 | 17 | Connecting rod |
| 3 | 1956 | Indianapolis | D-A Lubricants Racing | 1 | SWEIKERT Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 10 | 6 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Jones & Maley Cars | 4 | HANKS Sam | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 13 | 2 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | H.A. Chapman | 5 | LINDEN Andy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 9 | 27 | Oil leak |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Hoyt Machine/Fred Sommer | 10 | ELISIAN Ed | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 14 | 23 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 14 | VEITH Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 23 | 7 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Filter Queen/Ed Walsh | 19 | WARD Rodger | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 15 | 8 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Lindsey Hopkins | 24 | RATHMANN Jim | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 2 | 20 | Hydraulics |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Trio Brass Foundry / Anderson | 34 | TOLAN Johnnie | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 31 | 21 | Engine |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 42 | AGABASHIAN Fred | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 7 | 12 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | John Zink | 53 | RUTTMAN Troy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 11 | 31 | Spin |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | McNamara/Kalamazoo Sports | 73 | RATHMANN Dick | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 4 | 5 | |
| 1956 | Indianapolis | Belanger Motors | 99 | BETTENHAUSEN Tony | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 5 | 22 | Accident |
| 4 | 1957 | Indianapolis | Hoyt Machine/Fred Sommer | 5 | REECE Jimmy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 6 | 18 | Throttle |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Ray Brady | 15 | BONADIES Tony | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Sclavi & Amos | 55 | RUSSO Eddie | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 26 | 32 | Accident |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Helse / H.H. Johnson | 57 | DAYWALT Jimmy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 29 | 28 | Accident |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Braund Plywood | 67 | EDMUNDS Don | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Ed Gdula | 71 | FEDRICKS Johnny | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1957 | Indianapolis | Jones & Maley Cars | 95 | CHRISTIE Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 33 | 13 | |
| 5 | 1958 | Indianapolis | Ansted Rotary | 17 | BISCH Art | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Hoyt Machine/Fred Sommer | 24 | HARTLEY Gene | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Sumar/Chapman Root | 48 | UNSER Jerry | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Ray Brady | 58 | JOHNSON Van | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 65 | CHRISTIE Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 17 | 14 | Spin |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Kurtis-Kraft / Smith | 74 | HOMEIER Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Safety Auto Glass | 95 | HOMEIER Bill | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1958 | Indianapolis | Safety Auto Glass | 95 | WARRINER Leroy | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 6 | 1959 | Indianapolis | Safety Auto Glass | 17 | KAY Johnny | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1959 | Indianapolis | Ray Brady | 58 | McWITHEY Jim | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 33 | 16 | |
| 1959 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 65 | CHRISTIE Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 24 | 25 | Engine |
| 1959 | Indianapolis | Frank Arciero | 69 | TEMPLEMAN Shorty | Maserati V8 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1959 | Indianapolis | Speed International | 72 | ARNOLD Chuck | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |
| 1959 | Indianapolis | Wheeler-Foutch | 87 | AMICK Red | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 26 | 31 | Accident |
| 7 | 1960 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 26 | TEMPLEMAN Shorty | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 19 | 17 | |
| 1960 | Indianapolis | Federal Engineering | 38 | CHRISTIE Bob | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | 14 | 10 | |
| 1960 | Indianapolis | Ray Brady | 58 | DROLLINGER Lee | Offenhauser L4 | Firestone | | nq | |